The crisis in Australia with regards to racist attacks on Indian students has now blown over into a full-scale evaluation of whether Australia as a nation is racist. While it is unfair to judge an entire country for the misdeeds of a few demented individuals, one must bear in mind that a country is made up of its people, no matter what be their ideology, and the country must in effect take some of the brickbats for their views and opinions.
Australia is not new to accusations that it is racist, perhaps more because of the White Australia policy followed till the mid-1970's. While Australia wasn't alone at that time in trying to limit the numbers of non-Caucasian and non-European immigrants,
it certainly was the most determined of the lot, perhaps following South Africa in its zeal. While the architects of the policy stated that it had been justified by fears of a potential deterioration of living standards with the influx of such immigrants, their own views at other fora spelt things otherwise. The chief architect, Alfred Deakin, stated then, and I quote, "It is not the bad qualities, but the good qualities of these alien races that make them so dangerous to us. It is their inexhaustible energy, their power of applying themselves to new tasks, their endurance and low standard of living that make them such competitors." A fine reason to exclude people from your land...
The current financial crisis and the fact that India and China remain amongst the few economies that were relatively unscathed and are finding it comparitively easier to tide over the storm means that an already uneasy local populace has even more to fear from Indians and Chinese. Racism, to my mind, is a manifestation of the innermost fears and anxieties of the locals about the security of their livelihood, about their ability to compete with the immigrant population and their belief that even if they are unsuited for the job in question, they ought to receive the job, merely because they are the locals. This policy is akin to the sons-of-the-soil policy in India, and is no less deplorable.
In a globalised world, no nation can maintain its exclusivity. Australian mines served during the good times the industries of India and China, illustrating the link between the nations. But if, when the going gets tough, people wish to look inwards and cut off their links to the world, there is no greater tragedy in progress. If there is one nation that akin to the United States has welcomed those whom their homelands forsook or threw out, it is Australia.
Just as the US has benefited from the toils of its immigrants, so also has Australia. And they continue to do so. That in these times one's race makes one susceptible to hate crimes is not only tragic; it's fundamentally stupid and reprehensible.
The financial crisis has served to underline that the veins of the global economy run deep in every nation and every part of the globe. Tremors felt in one part are equally felt somewhere right across the planet, underlining the fact that there is no such thing as a localised issue anymore, at least not one that concerns trade, commerce and the exchange of ideas and opinions. We must be prepared to welcome people of all colours and hues, of all backgrounds, so long as they consent and submit themselves to the rule of law and do nothing to subvert the safety of our nations. Their ideas combined with ours could yield better results; that they are darker in skin tone doesn't lessen in any manner the value of their opinion nor does our being fair-skinned increase our ideas' worth.
One could look sympathetically at the concerns of common Australians and perhaps explain away these acts of madness, but somewhere one knows that this approach is not enough. That these concerns exist is true, but then they exist everywhere. Such acts haven't taken place there with such ferocity, have they? Though this is madness, there is a certain method to it, and failure to recognize the patterns could prove very dangerous for everyone concerned. The callousness and reluctance on the part of the local authorities to accept that there is something wrong makes matters worse. One wishes that those perpetrating these crimes remember that hate injures the hater more than the hated. The authorities would also do well to remember Mary Shelley's words where she says that it isn't charity but justice that is wanting in the world. If there are noxious weeds that are poisoning the crop of Australians, the authorities must be swift in uprooting them. Till such time, as Marcellus said, something is rotten in the state of Denmark.
6 comments:
Tolerance and acceptance are virtues which will help us prevent issues like this and many more. Good blog Reddy, keep it up. And written pretty soon after the incidents. Good work.
its just like the way MNS is harming maharashtra..
liked the pictures u used i the blog post..
one fine day students would say we want 10 marks extra in each paper since the live near the university or because they are local..
i think expecting some privileges or preference over your competition is wrong..
applying their logic , Australians should stop using their cell phones and electronic goods manufactured in Japan n China
heard that song Imagine by John Lennon? that would be my reply to all those ugly incidents taking place in this world
rather , i think expecting some privileges or preference over your competition PROVES YOU WEAK AND INCOMPETENT
Good piece.
My heart goes out to the families of the students studying in Australia. I'm sure it must be harrowing time for all of them and I pray that this situation improves quickly for their sake.
I don't think it is easy for the police to "prevent" such attacks but the least they can do is to bring the known offenders to justice. And if they want to restore a modicum of trust, they must make public the intentions of the criminals behind the attacks.
I can't wait to see the stats of number of Indian students flying to Aussieland next year. :)
P.S.: The use of imagery in this post has been simply wonderful!
Good piece. However, it is too early to classify all the recent attacks as cases of plain racism. They still might be. But, vandalism more often than not gets camouflaged by racism. There is a slight tendency on part of some people to read too much of "racism" even when such an element is not the primary issue.
Whenever instances of Racism occur, the media always play it up. They HAVE to play it up so that more eye balls can come in. However, since you and I have lived abroad for some time, you know it and I know it that such instances are common once you come out of India.
Will any news outlet highlight this aspect also that the stupidity of the students could have also led to this? It is only a possibility mind you, but it could happen. When we go abroad, university people tell us that we should not venture out at night.
These instances have happened in the night time, so maybe these students were probably going around and fooling around when they should have just been at home.
This is not to say though that the Aussies are angels. That country is as xenophobic as one can get. You only have to go back to the Bondi Beach race riots of 2004 to highlight this Xenophobia. However, I only wish that Media were not so careless, but this is the Stupid Indian Media Circus. What to do?
Post a Comment